Don't let anyone ever drag out that hoary old protest against homeschooling, "Oh, but your child won't have an opportunity to socialize with other kids." There are more social opportunities for homeschoolers available than we can possibly handle. And in far better social environments, too.
For instance, there's Scouting, where, despite any other objection you could make about it, the primary purpose of the organization is to learn how to develop friendships and place yourself in context with the wider community in a supportive environment. You can earn badges in conflict resolution and social manners - in addition to ones in elementary physics and computing. Or, there's martial arts classes, which give you exercise, physical skills, and humility while teaching you how to operate in a formal hierarchical social institution... and defend yourself against bullies. For that matter, there are chess schools/clubs, Lego classes, language classes, 4-H, sports, music, environmental groups and the entire range of service organizations. And church, if you're into that kind of thing. That's a freaking smorgasbord of social opportunities without having to add into it being imprisoned for six long hours each day into the same environment (essentially a pack of young animals vying for dominance) without the support of your family, with no way to retreat or take a break.
I'll save my screed against brainwashing and the origins of compulsory education for later. This may be a tricky topic for an educator to write about.
Public school is a snake pit, even for ordinary kids. I routinely hear or read people excuse this by claiming that kids won't learn how to handle adult life without learning how to endure abuse from peers in school; "oh, that's just part of growing up," I read. I'd like to know: to what adult life experience is this experience supposed to pertain? Aside from (possibly) the military or other institutions, in what other situation is an adult required to remain in the company of his or her age cohort with no ability to make choices about remaining, no way to avoid bullies, and no recourse for abuse? None. Not in this country. You are allowed to change jobs. You can leave your lunch table if you need to. And, I'd like to point out that this was not part of growing up for most of the history of humans. Psychologically and socially, we've evolved to be raised by an extended family unit or small group. This is also another pet topic... I'm on a roll with issues that have been simmering for decades, I believe.
One thing that school does teach well depends partially on the psychology of the kid. In learning how to deal with an unreasonable and legal-bound system, you can learn either powerlessness, how to control your frustration, or how to bully others. That middle possibility is obviously the best, if it can be achieved, but to anyone paying attention to the major K-12 educational issues, it's clearly the least possible.
I don't know if my older daughter will ever forgive me for not homeschooling her. I hear the note of resentment sounded at least once a week.
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Saturday, September 6, 2008
Back-to-Park Week
This short week was jam-packed with meetings in parks to launch the school year - homeschooling park day, the county homeschool back-to-school picnic, scouting... after all the stress of meeting new people in new situations, it was a definite dud as far as schoolwork was concerned. Rose couldn't focus on anything. Fortunately, we had a very productive school week last week and could afford to take it easy. She got a lot of exercise and social practice in! It's one of those times when I'm again very, very glad that we chose to learn at home so that we have that flexibility.
And, Rose pulled on her 'safety net' tags for each excursion by herself - without my actually even remembering about them. So I do feel that it was ultimately a good choice to have them made. I suspect that just wearing them as a backup plan has given Rose some confidence - sort of like Dumbo's magic crow feather, a sort of talisman as well as a safety net. About a week ago, Rose got "lost" in the library - I was actually only a few aisles away, but she was focused on finding books and didn't notice where I was. I came out of the aisles to see her standing by the librarian's desk and talking to the librarian. She had remembered to do exactly the right thing, and while she was anxious, she wasn't in a desperate panic. "A little anxiety, Mom," the librarian said, and she gave me a look to tell me that she'd noticed that it was a little unusual. I nodded, yep, and praised Rose for remaining calm and remembering where to go for help. It's a big step forward!
And, Rose pulled on her 'safety net' tags for each excursion by herself - without my actually even remembering about them. So I do feel that it was ultimately a good choice to have them made. I suspect that just wearing them as a backup plan has given Rose some confidence - sort of like Dumbo's magic crow feather, a sort of talisman as well as a safety net. About a week ago, Rose got "lost" in the library - I was actually only a few aisles away, but she was focused on finding books and didn't notice where I was. I came out of the aisles to see her standing by the librarian's desk and talking to the librarian. She had remembered to do exactly the right thing, and while she was anxious, she wasn't in a desperate panic. "A little anxiety, Mom," the librarian said, and she gave me a look to tell me that she'd noticed that it was a little unusual. I nodded, yep, and praised Rose for remaining calm and remembering where to go for help. It's a big step forward!
Tuesday, August 26, 2008
New and re-recognized stuff
Every once in a while, I see something that Rose does that gives me a fresh sense of dismay that I didn't recognize what was going on with her earlier in her life. If only I had realized her difficulties earlier, I keep thinking, I could have helped her along over some sticky parts of life, taken steps to make sure her public school experiences were less overwhelming or negative. At least that's what I keep thinking, realistic or not.
She's been a little high-strung the past couple of days, as I've mentioned. Just a little while ago, a piercing shriek alerted me to the fact that she'd found a spider on her pillow. She came running into my room with an expression of complete internal focus, grabbed the edge of my robe as it was laying on the bed, and began rolling the edge of it with her fingers in a ritualistic way while she explained the spider situation. She did not look at me.
That gave me a slight shock. When she was a toddler, she used to rub her fingers along the edges of her blanket in just the same intense way. I just had thought, well, that's how she is, and made sure that she could get her blanket when she needed it. I never thought for a moment that it was some kind of sensory ritual, or rather, I never thought of it as something unusual. So is it, really? How is it unremarkable at two and eye-opening at eight? And further, is it really eye-opening at eight? Do neurotypical eight-year-olds not do this? I suspect not for any number of reasons, but I'm not completely sure.
Rose's grandmother keeps asking if Rose is "getting worse," because to her, it seems that's so. I keep trying to explain that it just appears to be that way since behaviors that were OK for a young kid aren't for an older one. I keep finding situations or behaviors like this one where she has not essentially changed since babyhood, and I keep being shocked at their new interpretation in light of her autism.
I do think the toewalking I mention in the last post is new, though. I don't really remember her toewalking at any point in childhood prior to this. Sometimes I really don't know what to think - or what to do, if anything.
She's been a little high-strung the past couple of days, as I've mentioned. Just a little while ago, a piercing shriek alerted me to the fact that she'd found a spider on her pillow. She came running into my room with an expression of complete internal focus, grabbed the edge of my robe as it was laying on the bed, and began rolling the edge of it with her fingers in a ritualistic way while she explained the spider situation. She did not look at me.
That gave me a slight shock. When she was a toddler, she used to rub her fingers along the edges of her blanket in just the same intense way. I just had thought, well, that's how she is, and made sure that she could get her blanket when she needed it. I never thought for a moment that it was some kind of sensory ritual, or rather, I never thought of it as something unusual. So is it, really? How is it unremarkable at two and eye-opening at eight? And further, is it really eye-opening at eight? Do neurotypical eight-year-olds not do this? I suspect not for any number of reasons, but I'm not completely sure.
Rose's grandmother keeps asking if Rose is "getting worse," because to her, it seems that's so. I keep trying to explain that it just appears to be that way since behaviors that were OK for a young kid aren't for an older one. I keep finding situations or behaviors like this one where she has not essentially changed since babyhood, and I keep being shocked at their new interpretation in light of her autism.
I do think the toewalking I mention in the last post is new, though. I don't really remember her toewalking at any point in childhood prior to this. Sometimes I really don't know what to think - or what to do, if anything.
Monday, August 25, 2008
Back to (Home)School
Today has had so much packed into it that it feels like it's been at least two days. We've had a fairly quiet summer. We've done some art projects and had some low-key fun, including a fantastic picnic with the local Asperger's society. And now we've had a hectic couple of days, with a visit from Rose's cousin yesterday and the official start of the school year today for both Rose and her sister.
Rose's quirks all rise to the surface when she's stressed, of course. Some of them are relatively innocuous, like finger-flicking and toe-walking, others become more obvious, like withdrawing or not being able to register someone talking. Then there's the panic attacks and emotional explosions over things like... clicking the link to the wrong video on YouTube, or the fact that the screensaver went on.
But overall, I have to say that this is really damn mild anxiety compared to say, starting a new school year at a public school. And in fact, some of the anxiety Rose is experiencing now, I believe to be linked to the emotional triggers of "starting school" from the past couple of years. She freaked out over clicking the wrong link to a video because she felt as though "everyone" (?) knew that she messed up again.
Very, very fortunately, this particular video we were about to watch was Phil Plait's piece for kids on scientific methodology - and how science is about trying things out, including being wrong and correcting oneself. It made for a great support to say, "It's OK, even scientists (like you want to be!) make mistakes or are wrong, it's completely expected, and in fact mistakes are great, because you get to learn from them."
We ended the school day with a distinct sense of satisfaction. And some ice cream, of course.
Rose's quirks all rise to the surface when she's stressed, of course. Some of them are relatively innocuous, like finger-flicking and toe-walking, others become more obvious, like withdrawing or not being able to register someone talking. Then there's the panic attacks and emotional explosions over things like... clicking the link to the wrong video on YouTube, or the fact that the screensaver went on.
But overall, I have to say that this is really damn mild anxiety compared to say, starting a new school year at a public school. And in fact, some of the anxiety Rose is experiencing now, I believe to be linked to the emotional triggers of "starting school" from the past couple of years. She freaked out over clicking the wrong link to a video because she felt as though "everyone" (?) knew that she messed up again.
Very, very fortunately, this particular video we were about to watch was Phil Plait's piece for kids on scientific methodology - and how science is about trying things out, including being wrong and correcting oneself. It made for a great support to say, "It's OK, even scientists (like you want to be!) make mistakes or are wrong, it's completely expected, and in fact mistakes are great, because you get to learn from them."
We ended the school day with a distinct sense of satisfaction. And some ice cream, of course.
Saturday, July 12, 2008
Medical ID Tags
Today, Rose and I went to the county fair. What a blast! But entirely a hairy experience - crowded, noisy, overstimulating, full of unpredictability both good and bad. Rosie was having a ton of fun but was also pretty agitated. She kept darting in different directions in the crowd and could not hear me at all. If I put a hand on her to guide her, she flinched or skittered away because her senses were so keyed up it felt like I was clawing her. She's gotten too big to hold her hand, partly because I can hardly hold her - she's too strong.
It was getting pretty grim, but I spotted a set of dog tags in an engraving stall and wondered - why on earth hadn't we done this before? I had them put the usual name and number on it, then on the bottom line, "PANIC ATTACKS / AUTISM" should she find herself lost and freaky and incoherent.
She seems a little embarrassed but also relieved, saying they were like a safety net. Now I feel guilty and unsure. Was I right to put "autism" rather than "asperger's" so that emergency personnel would treat her according to a - hopefully - more familiar protocol if she was having the screaming heebie-jeebies? She does seem OK about it - but I worry about the more subtle effect of what I've done. Did I just hand my otherwise articulate and capable kid a big metal "incapable" label?
oh, augh.
It was getting pretty grim, but I spotted a set of dog tags in an engraving stall and wondered - why on earth hadn't we done this before? I had them put the usual name and number on it, then on the bottom line, "PANIC ATTACKS / AUTISM" should she find herself lost and freaky and incoherent.
She seems a little embarrassed but also relieved, saying they were like a safety net. Now I feel guilty and unsure. Was I right to put "autism" rather than "asperger's" so that emergency personnel would treat her according to a - hopefully - more familiar protocol if she was having the screaming heebie-jeebies? She does seem OK about it - but I worry about the more subtle effect of what I've done. Did I just hand my otherwise articulate and capable kid a big metal "incapable" label?
oh, augh.
Monday, July 7, 2008
Pros and Cons of School at a Distance
Yesterday, I found Rosie making imaginary friends. She was coloring pictures of kids and giving them names. "These are the students I hope to have, when I'm a teacher," she said. I thought about it, and it seemed to me that when I'm a teacher sounded more like if I had status in school. "What about schoolmates?" I asked. "Yes," Rosie said, "these are the students I hope I would have in my class." "If you went back to school?" I asked. "Yes, if I ever go back to school."
Naturally I am squirming. This is my fault. At this point I am doing exactly what I didn't want to do - isolate her. And it's not necessary, either, since there are so very many homeschool groups. I just have been struggling to balance the new pattern and have not stepped out to find social opportunities fast enough.
I asked Rosie if she thought she would ever want to go back to regular school, and what the good and bad parts of school were. "I miss the playground," she said. "All the kids playing at once." This surprised me, since she typically played on the edges of the playground without anyone. "And I miss my friend." This is the one friend she made, a kindergartener. I haven't tried to maintain the friendship for her because the other child is so young. "The bad parts are that I have to concentrate, and I get distracted all the time." Yes, I tell her, if you're distracted a lot, then it's hard to concentrate.
"Also I hate math." This one makes me grin - so typical a kid's comment, even from someone who was getting awards in math despite everything - but then I realize it's related to the other bad parts - being distracted and having a hard time concentrating. At home, she studies math hanging off the couch upside down, sometimes in Japanese. Which... helps her concentrate. Math is an enormous pleasure for her when approached without stress, and she does very well. I don't see the elementary school putting up with that.
Rosie's dad insists, and I still do agree, that we have done the right thing in removing her from the ultra-stressful environment of public school. What we haven't done right YET is make sure the social bases are covered, and the theraputic bases.
Naturally I am squirming. This is my fault. At this point I am doing exactly what I didn't want to do - isolate her. And it's not necessary, either, since there are so very many homeschool groups. I just have been struggling to balance the new pattern and have not stepped out to find social opportunities fast enough.
I asked Rosie if she thought she would ever want to go back to regular school, and what the good and bad parts of school were. "I miss the playground," she said. "All the kids playing at once." This surprised me, since she typically played on the edges of the playground without anyone. "And I miss my friend." This is the one friend she made, a kindergartener. I haven't tried to maintain the friendship for her because the other child is so young. "The bad parts are that I have to concentrate, and I get distracted all the time." Yes, I tell her, if you're distracted a lot, then it's hard to concentrate.
"Also I hate math." This one makes me grin - so typical a kid's comment, even from someone who was getting awards in math despite everything - but then I realize it's related to the other bad parts - being distracted and having a hard time concentrating. At home, she studies math hanging off the couch upside down, sometimes in Japanese. Which... helps her concentrate. Math is an enormous pleasure for her when approached without stress, and she does very well. I don't see the elementary school putting up with that.
Rosie's dad insists, and I still do agree, that we have done the right thing in removing her from the ultra-stressful environment of public school. What we haven't done right YET is make sure the social bases are covered, and the theraputic bases.
Asperger's in Higher Ed
As a higher ed developer and instructor I'm naturally interested in, and concerned about, that transitional period into adulthood. I may not like all of the direction of the coverage about the 'rise in autism,' but I am definitely glad it's raising the awareness level of instructors everywhere. I found an article by a professor at the University of Alabama with an interesting slant - without working with the school's disability service, and without any declaration from his student, he perceived that his student needed a different approach and attempted to adjust his teaching accordingly. Not all instructors can be bothered. Kudos to Stephen Yoder!
http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2008/07/07/yoder
http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2008/07/07/yoder
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)